Edinburgh - A Victorian silver salver together with an Old Sheffield Plate example

Edinburgh - A Victorian silver salver together with an Old Sheffield Plate example, mark of James McKay, 1840, 'Chippendale' style with shell and scroll rim, the field with foliate engraving around a central monogrammed cartouche, raised on 3 applied cast shell and scroll feet, 27cm diameter, 530.6g (17ozt); the OSP example of similar style with gadrooned rim, the field with a border of foliate engraving and with a central monogram, raised on 3 applied cast shell and scroll feet, 30cm diameter (2)